IBO–01

INTERNATIONAL BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT

Part–A: Comment on any FOUR of the following statements (5 marks each)   |   Part–B: Attempt all questions
1(a)
“Basic functions, processes and techniques of international business are essentially the same as those involved in domestic business.” (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: International Business and Domestic Business are founded on the same managerial principles. Both planning, organisation, directing and control of business activities are involved. It is important to understand how similar functions are performed differently across national boundaries.

Explanation
Common Management Functions: Both types involve production, finance, HR, marketing, and logistics.
Similar Techniques: Decision making, forecasting, communications and control methods are identical.
Environmental Differences: International businesses face diverse political systems, economic systems, legal systems, and cultural systems.
The Need for Adaptation: Firms adapt their product, marketing and pricing strategies to foreign markets. Risk & Uncertainty: Foreign operations involve trade barriers, exchange-rate risks and regulatory issues.
Operational Standard: Cost management, quality control and productivity techniques are unchanged.

Conclusion: The statement remains true because business functions are based on the same foundation. Only differences in external environments across countries can cause variations.

Memory Help: F-T-E.A.R.O.D.I. → Functions – Techniques – Environment – Adaptation – Risk — Operations — Decisions & Implementation
1(b)
“Global environment exerts influence over domestic as well as overseas operations of a company.” (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: The global environment is composed of international economic trends and world financial systems. It also includes global institutions. The influence of the global environment reaches domestic as well as foreign operations. In an interconnected global economy, it is essential to have a good understanding of this.

Explanation
• Markets are interconnected: Booms and recessions around the world can affect demand in your own country.
• Currency Changes: Currency fluctuations affect domestic pricing and abroad profitability.
• Institutions international: Rules of the WTO influence production policies, import policies, and market access.
• Competition in the Global Market: Foreign competitors are present even if domestic firms do not operate abroad.
• Technological Innovations: Global changes affect production processes all over the world.
• Trade Agreements, Free Trade Areas (FTAs) and regional blocs influence tariffs on domestic and foreign markets.
• Capital mobility: global finance impacts investment decisions, borrowing costs and more.
• Political risks: Global political tensions impact supply chains and market stability.

Conclusion: The global environment shapes domestic and international operations. For firms to stay competitive and compliant, they must monitor global trends continuously.

Memory Help: M-E-I.C.T.A.C.P. → Markets – Exchange rates – Institutions – Competition, Technology, Agreements, Capital and Politics
1(c)
“Countries running deficits in their balance of payments accounts generally impose controls on movement of foreign exchange out of their economies.” (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: A balance of payments deficit (BOP) is a situation in which a foreign exchange outflow from a nation exceeds the inflow. Countries with persistent deficits adopt corrective measures in order to protect their reserves. Exchange control is a common tool.

Explanation
• Shortage of Foreign Exchange: The deficit reduces foreign reserves, creating pressure on the financial system.
• Need for Conservation: Exchange Controls Help Preserve Foreign Exchange for Essential Uses
• Restrictions on Payments: The government limits foreign travel, remittances or non-essential imports.
• Prioritisation: Basic goods, such as raw materials, medicines and machinery, are given priority.
• License for Import: All imports must be licensed to prevent unnecessary outflow.
• Controlling Capital Outflows: Restrictions stop citizens and businesses from sending money abroad.
• Stabilisation Measures: Helps to maintain currency stability and restore BOP equilibrium.
• Administrative Control: The Central Bank monitors and approves foreign exchange transactions.

Conclusion: The statement has been proven correct, as exchange control measures are widely used to correct the BOP. It is a measure that protects foreign currency reserves and promotes economic stability.

Memory Help: S-C.R.P.I.C.S.M. → Shortage – Conservation – Restrictions Priority – Import licensing Capital Control – Stability & Monitoring
1(d)
"Free Trade is Always Better Than No Trade" (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: Free trade is the unrestricted flow of goods and services between national borders, without tariffs or administrative restrictions. Trade theories from the classical and neoclassical periods show that countries that trade freely according to comparative benefit both gain through increased output, lower prices, and better welfare. Autarky (no-trade) restricts countries to their own domestic production capabilities, reducing their efficiency and consumer choices.

Explanation
• Free Trade: When goods are free to move without restrictions on tariffs and quantities, markets can operate according to relative costs.
• Comparative advantages basis: Country specialisation in goods where relative productivity is high; this ensures an efficient global resource allocation.
• Specialisation Benefits: Each country concentrates production on the products it is most efficient at producing, increasing global output.
• Mutually Benefiting Exchange: Trade is conducted at a common ratio of exchange between domestic opportunity costs ratios (e.g., 3/5 to 1/4 ratios between wheat and cloth), allowing mutual benefit.
• Consumers Beyond Production Frontier: Through trade, countries have more options for consumption because they can get goods cheaper than they could produce domestically.

Conclusion: The statement has a broad basis of truth because it allows for specialisation in accordance with comparative advantages, increases output and consumption, and improves the welfare. Compared to autarky, free trade brings greater efficiency, more competitive prices, and a wider variety of products.

Memory help: "F.C.S.E.C.W.A." → Free movement of goods – Comparative advantage – Specialisation – Exchange ratio benefit – Consumption gain – Welfare Improvement – Autarky = lower efficiency
1(e)
“Theory of comparative advantage provides the basis for trade.” (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: Comparative advantage is a theory developed by David Ricardo that explains the reasons for international trade. It focuses on relative efficiency differences rather than absolute production costs. It is the theoretical base of trade flows.

Explanation
• Relative efficiency principle: Specialization of goods at low relative costs.
• Mutual Gains: Both trade countries will benefit even if they are both more efficient at trading in certain goods.
• Specialisation: Production shifts towards goods where comparative advantage is present.
• Increased Production: Global output increases due to the efficient allocation of resources.
• Export Import Logic: Countries import goods that are advantageous and export those that are not.
• Labour Productivity Based: Ricardo based his cost analysis on the single factor of labour productivity.
• Trade Pattern Analysis: Comparative advantages predict which goods each nation trades.
• Modern Theories still build upon this fundamental idea.

Conclusion: The statement was correct because the comparative advantage explained logically the specialisation and trade advantages. It remains the primary justification for trade.

Memory Help: R-B-S.O.E.L.P.F. → Relative efficiency, Benefits, Specialisations and Outputs. Export/Import.
1(f)
"According to Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson theorem, a country which is relatively abundant in labour will have a comparative advantage in the labour-intensive goods." (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: The Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson (HOS) theorem explains the pattern of international trade based on factor endowments. Comparative advantage is determined by the differences in labour and capital availability between countries. Theorem: A country will tend to export goods that use its plentiful factor intensively and import goods that use its scarce factor intensively.

Explanation
• Factor-Endowment Basis: The relative availability of labour and capital in different countries is different.
• Labour Abundance: A labour-abundant country is one that has a greater proportion of workers in relation to capital.
• Cost Advantage: Labour-abundant countries can produce labour-intensive goods at a lower relative cost.
• Specialisation pattern: They are specialized in the production and exportation of labour-intensive products such as textiles or garments.
• Importing capital-intensive goods: They import products that require high capital expenditure, such as machinery or technology.
• Relative Prices of Factors: Abundant factor prices are lower; scarce factor prices are higher, reinforcing the comparative advantages.
• Trade Result: The specialisation of countries based on their factor endowments increases the total global output, and all countries benefit.

Conclusion: So, the HOS Theorem accurately predicts that countries with an abundance of labour will export goods that are labour-intensive and import those that are capital-intensive. This explains trade patterns between countries that have different factor endowments.

Memory help: "A.C.L.S.I." → A - Abundant factor, C - Cheaper production, L - Labour-intensive exports, S - Specialisation, I - Import capital-intensive goods
Q2
Define international business environments. Separate micro- and macro-environments. What impact does the economic environment have on a company's business decisions? (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
Introduction: Business is an activity that involves industry and commerce. These activities are international businesses if they cross national borders. It is not so much the basic functions that change, but rather the environments within which they are performed.

1. Definition of International Business Environment (6 MARKS)
Meaning of the word environment: An environment is the surroundings or milieu that surrounds a firm, made up of external actors.
Business Environment: This is the collection of actors and forces that surround and influence an organization's operations and decisions.
The International Dimension: When forces of this nature operate at national, foreign, and global levels, they create the international environment.
Careful study is required: A company must thoroughly examine the environment, as external actors and forces have a significant impact on its performance.
Unfamiliar Foreign conditions: An international business environment is complex because companies must operate under unfamiliar foreign conditions, in contrast to the relatively familiar domestic environments.
Impacts on Performance and Decisions: The international forces have a powerful impact on the business decisions. This makes understanding the international business climate essential for success.

2. Micro and Macro Environments (7 MARKS)
Basis of DifferenceMicro EnvironmentMacro Environment
1. MeaningRefers to actors in the firm’s immediate environment that directly influence decisions.Refers to larger external forces that shape the overall business climate.
2. ElementsIncludes competitors, suppliers, intermediaries, service organisations and customers.Includes economic, financial, social, cultural, political, legal and ecological forces.
3. Nature of InfluenceInfluence is direct and specific, affecting day-to-day operational decisions.Influence is general and indirect, shaping long-term opportunities and threats.
4. Operational LevelOperates close to the firm within the immediate business network.Operates at home (local), host (foreign) and global levels.
5. Level of ControlFirms can partly control or influence these actors through strategies and relationships.Firms have little or no control; they must adapt to external circumstances.
6. Impact on BusinessAffects product design, pricing, promotion, distribution and competition.Affects economic policies, market conditions, threats and opportunities.
7. Focus AreaFocuses on business relations and operational linkages.Focuses on economic trends, societal patterns, regulations and global forces.

3. Business Decisions and the Economic Environment (6 MARKS)
Market Size & Nature: Economic Environment helps a firm to know what the nature of the market is and how large it is. This can influence the decision whether or not to enter the country.
Entry Decision: Your answers will determine your decision to enter the foreign market.
The choice of strategy: It defines marketing strategies and operational strategies that are required to run a successful business.
Level of Development: A high level of development is associated with a higher demand, better infrastructure, and a lower cost.
Income Segmentation: Indicators similar to GDP and per capita income guide product ranges, pricing and target segments.
Sectoral composition: Sectoral distribution (agriculture or manufacturing) guides focus on the product.
Expenditure pattern and Infrastructure: Spending patterns and infrastructures (transport, finances, communications) have an impact on distribution channels and logistics costs.

Conclusion: The International business environment is made up of external and largely uncontrollable factors operating on the national, international, and global levels. The micro-macro differentiation clarifies direct actors from wider forces. The economic environment plays the most decisive role in market entry, product-mix, pricing, and overall strategy formulation.

Memory Help (Easy Syllable): "M.M.E.D.I.S.P."
Micro = immediate players
Macro: broad country/global forces
E External
D - Development level guides market entry
I - Income & GNP guide product mix
S Sectoral spending & GNP shape focus
P - Policies & BOP shape trade/investment decisions
3
Explain the modern theory of trade (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
Introduction: Classical theories and neoclassical theory explained trade through comparative benefit and the endowments of factors with perfect competition and constant returns to scale. In reality, world trade is characterized by Product Differentiation, Economies of Scale and Intra-industry Trade. To explain the patterns, economists developed theories of modern trade.

1. Distinction from Classical and Neoclassical Presumptions
Changes in Market Structure: Current theories assume that there is monopolistic, oligopolistic or even perfect competition.
Product Diversification: Firms are producing differentiated products instead of homogeneous products, giving each firm a certain market power.
Economies of Scale: Instead of constant returns to size, they assume economies of scale. As a result, average costs drop as output increases.

2. Nature of Product Differentiation
Horizontal Differentiation: The products are similar in quality, but they differ in design or variety (e.g., red pen vs. blue pen, wood vs. steel furniture, white wine and red wine).
Vertical Differentiation: Products are differentiated by Quality Levels.

3. Role of Economies of Scale
Economy of Scale: Output more than doubles, even though labor is less than doubled. This illustrates increasing returns to scale.
Product Specialisation: With a fixed supply of labour and the same technology, each country can only produce small quantities. If they specialize in one product, however, both products are produced at a higher level.

4. Trade within the same industry and Identical Nations
Similar Technology and Factor Endowments: Trade is possible when countries share identical technologies and factors.
Intraindustry Trade: New theories explain the trade within a single industry. An example would be if one country exported white wine but imported red wine. Both require similar technologies.
Consumer Preference for Variety: The consumer prefers variety. Trade enables access to more differentiated products and increases welfare, even between similar countries.

5. Modern Theories and Their Significance
Real Trade Patterns: The majority of global trade is intraindustry. This cannot be explained by classical or neoclassical models. Modern theories fill the gap.
Policy implications: They stress the importance of scale economies of products, product variety and strategic behaviour in trade policies and industrial strategies.

Conclusion: Modern theories on trade are based on imperfect market competition, product differentiation, and economies of scale. The authors show that trade can be caused not only by differences in factor endowments or technology, but also by scale benefits and consumers' love of choice.

Memory help (Easy Snippet)
"D-P-E-I-V-S"
D → Departure From Perfect Competition
P → Product differentiation (horizontal & vertical)
E → Economy of scale
I → Intraindustry Trade between Similar Countries
V → Variety preferences of consumers
S → Similar endowments, yet trade occurs
4(a)
(a) Terms of Trade (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: Terms of Trade express the relationship of prices between exports and imports. It shows the buying power that a nation's exports have in order to acquire imports from other countries.

Key Points:
1. Shows how many units a country is entitled to receive in exchange for one unit.
2. Rate of Price: The ratio between export and import prices expressed in percentage.
3. Commodity Terms of Trade: Measures purchasing power of exports using the export and import unit value indexes.
4. Terms of trade improved: Export prices rising faster than import prices.
5. A decline in purchasing power when import prices rise faster.
6. A Problem for Developing Countries: Primary goods-exporting countries often suffer from deteriorating terms of trade because of low price and income elasticity of demand.

Conclusion: Terms of trade show how advantageous or unfavourable a trading country is. Improved terms increase purchasing power for exports while declining ones signal policy issues.

Memory Help: “P” → Relative index: Improvement, Deterioration and Developing-country Problem.
4(b)
(b) Free trade and gains from trade (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: Free trade is the international exchange of products and services without quantitative or tariff restrictions. Trade is a result of countries specialising according to their comparative advantage. It allows for an increase in world production and welfare.

The Free Trade Act and Trade Gains:
1. Definition of free trade: Trade crosses borders freely and without restrictions.
2. The Comparative Advantage Base: Specialize in goods where productivity is high.
3. Specialisation: As a result of specialisation, countries concentrate on their own products.
4. World output gain: Increase in global production when countries specialise according to relative opportunity costs.
5. Mutually Beneficial Exchange: Exchanges are made within an agreed price range (e.g., wheat-cloth ratio between 3/5 and 1/4).
6. Consumer Gain: International trade allows countries to purchase goods beyond their production frontier.

Conclusion: Free trade maximises its benefit by allowing countries to specialise according to their comparative advantages. They can also exchange in favourable ratios and increase incomes and welfare levels beyond the autarky level.

Memory Aid: F-C.S.O.E.C.P.D. → Free movement – Comparative advantage – Specialisation – Output gain – Exchange benefit – Consumption gain – Price advantage – Development
4(c)
(c) Balance of Payments (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: The BOP is a systematic record that shows the country's international transactions. It is a statement that shows inflows and outflows for a specific period.

Balance of Payments:
1. Definition: A systematised statement of receipts, payments and international transactions.
2. Double Entry Basis: Each transaction appears twice – credit and debit – ensuring normal balance.
3. Current Account: Records goods, services, income flows and unilateral transfers.
4. Capital Account: Includes long-term as well as short-term movements such as FDIs and portfolio flows.
5. Reserves Account: Shows IMF transactions, SDRs, foreign exchange reserves and changes in gold.
6. Deficit/Surplus Meaning: When debits exceed credits (deficit) and vice-versa (surplus).

Conclusion: BOP offers a detailed picture of international economic activity. It is vital to monitor external stability as well as formulate policies related to trade, currency rates and investments.

Memory Help: “DCRDIP” → Definition – Current – Capital – Reserves – Deficit/Surplus – Indicator – Policy
4(d)
(d) Special Drawing Rights (5 MARKS)
5 MARKS
Introduction: The IMF developed Special Drawing Rights (SDRs) in 1969 as an alternative to gold and US dollar reserves. SDRs make up part of international reserves for member countries and support global liquidity.

Special Drawing Rights:
1. Creation: Created as a result of an IMF-approved decision to improve international liquidity.
2. Purpose: Releasing monetary reserves away from dependence on the US dollar or gold.
3. Initial Allocation: A total of 3.5 billion SDRs were issued in 1970-72.
4. Nature: They are reserve assets that IMF members have been allocated.
5. Use as Reserve Currency: Using SDRs, countries can obtain foreign exchange to settle international transactions.
6. Unit of Account: The IMF values its accounts in SDRs.

Conclusion: SDRs play an important role in international reserves. By providing an internationally stable reserve asset, SDRs enhance global monetary and liquidity stability.

Memory Help: C-P-A.R.U.V.N. → Creation – Purpose – Allocation – Reserve use – Unit of account – Valuation – No conditionality
5
Distinguish between tariff and non-tariff barriers. Explain various non-tariff barriers which are normally used to restrict international trade. (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
Introduction: When regulating the international trade of goods, governments use trade barriers to correct balance-of-payments problems and protect domestic industries. Tariff barriers increase the cost of imports through duties and taxes, while non-tariff barriers (NTBs) restrict imports more indirectly, administratively and quantitatively.

Difference Between Tariff and Non-Tariff Barriers (8 MARKS)
Basis for DifferenceTariff BarriersNon-Tariff Barriers
1. MeaningTaxes/duties on imported (or exported) goods.Other trade restrictions than tariffs used to restrict or regulate imports.
2. Method of RestrictionIncrease price of imports through duties.Restrict via quantity limits, regulations or administrative procedures.
3. FormsAd valorem, specific or compound duties.Quotas, licensing, standards, customs procedures, exchange controls, etc.
4. TransparencyTransparent and measurable.Less transparent – hidden in standards, regulations and procedures.
5. Revenue ImpactGenerates customs revenue for government.Does not generate revenue.
6. FlexibilityEasily changed by altering tariff schedule.Fine control possible through varying quotas, licensing conditions, technical standards.

Various Non-Tariff Barriers Normally Used to Restrict International Trade (10 MARKS)
Import Quotas: Direct quantitative restriction on the volume or value of a commodity that can be imported in a given period. Once quota is exhausted, no further imports allowed.
Import Licensing: Imports allowed only against a licence issued by government. Licensing authority can restrict number of licences or impose strict eligibility conditions.
Voluntary Export Restraints (VERs): “Voluntary” agreement by exporting country to limit its exports at the request of importing country (e.g., textiles, steel).
Technical, Sanitary & Health Standards: Stringent quality, safety, packaging, labelling and technical specifications that foreign goods find difficult to meet.
Customs Valuation & Procedures: Complicated documentation, slow clearance, arbitrary valuation of imports act as hidden barriers.
Foreign Exchange Controls: In times of foreign exchange shortage, government allocates forex only for priority imports, thereby restricting others.
Government Procurement Policies: “Buy national” policies or preference to domestic suppliers in public purchases.
Anti-dumping Duties & Countervailing Duties: Used (sometimes misused) to counter alleged dumping or subsidised exports.

Conclusion: Both tariff and non-tariff barriers regulate international trade. However, with progressive reduction of tariffs under WTO, NTBs have become the most widely used instrument of protection. Understanding these barriers is essential for trade analysis and negotiations.

Memory Help (Mnemonics)
QUOTAS → L (Licensing) → V (VERs) → T (Technical standards) → C (Customs hurdles) → F (Forex control) → G (Government procurement)
Q6
What do you mean by Globalisation? Describe various forces of globalisation. Do you think that India has entered the globalisation era significantly? (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
Introduction / Meaning of Globalisation (5 MARKS)
Globalisation is the process of growing economic integration and interdependence of countries through cross-border movement of goods, services, capital, technology, information and (to some extent) labour. It results in the creation of a single world market and production system where events in one part of the globe rapidly affect others. It is reflected in the rising share of international trade and capital flows in world GDP and the emergence of global production networks of multinational corporations.

Various Forces (Drivers) of Globalisation (8 MARKS)
Expanding World Trade: Rapid increase in global trade (faster than world output) due to falling transport costs and better logistics.
Transnational Corporations (TNCs): TNCs establish production facilities across countries, creating global value chains and massive FDI flows.
WTO-led Trade Liberalisation: Multilateral reduction of tariffs and non-tariff barriers, opening of markets, and enforcement of common trade rules.
Technological Advancement: Revolutionary progress in transport (containerisation, air cargo), communication (internet, satellite) and information technology drastically reduced cost and time of moving goods, services and knowledge.
Integration of Financial Markets: 24-hour global capital markets, free movement of portfolio investment and speculative capital.
Policy Reforms in Developing Countries: Shift from import-substitution to export-promotion, removal of capital controls and privatisation.
Regional Trading Blocs: EU, NAFTA (now USMCA), ASEAN, MERCOSUR, etc., created larger integrated markets.

Has India Entered the Globalisation Era Significantly? (6 MARKS)
Yes – strong evidence:
1991 Liberalisation: Abolition of industrial licensing, drastic reduction of tariffs, removal of quantitative restrictions, opening to FDI.
Sharp Rise in Trade: India’s trade-to-GDP ratio rose from ~15% in 1991 to over 40% in recent years.
FDI Inflows: From virtually zero to billions of dollars annually; India now among top FDI destinations.
Integration of Services & IT: World leader in IT/ITeS exports; Indian software professionals and companies operate globally.
Participation in Global Value Chains: Automobile components, pharmaceuticals, textiles, etc.
Capital Market Integration: Indian companies raise funds abroad (GDRs/ADRs), FII inflows, overseas acquisitions by Indian firms (Tata, Reliance, etc.).

Conclusion (1 MARK)
India has moved from a closed, highly regulated economy to a significantly open and globally integrated one. Though some sectors still remain protected and challenges persist, India has undoubtedly entered the globalisation era in a major way.

Memory Help: Forces → “T-T-W-T-F-P-R”
T Trade expansion • T TNCs • W WTO liberalisation • T Technology • F Financial integration • P Policy reforms • R Regional blocs

India → “1991 → Trade ↑ • FDI ↑ • IT ↑ • Capital ↑”
Q7
What is a TNC? Why do firms become transnational? Discuss the main advantages and disadvantages of TNCs’ operations for the host country and the home country. (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
1. What is a TNC? (4 MARKS)
A Transnational Corporation (TNC) is a large enterprise that owns and controls production facilities (factories, offices, R&D centres) in several countries while maintaining centralised strategic decision-making in its home country. It operates through a network of subsidiaries, affiliates and joint ventures across the globe, pursuing global profit maximisation rather than national objectives.

2. Why do firms become transnational? (5 MARKS)
• Market-seeking: To enter large or growing foreign markets directly instead of just exporting.
• Tariff-jumping: To avoid import duties by producing inside the foreign market.
• Resource-seeking: To access raw materials, cheap labour, or skilled manpower abroad.
• Efficiency-seeking: To take advantage of lower production costs and achieve economies of scale.
• Technology exploitation & protection: To utilise proprietary technology globally and protect it from imitation.
• Risk diversification: To spread political, exchange-rate and market risks across countries.
• Host-country incentives: Tax holidays, subsidies, infrastructure offered by governments.

3. Advantages for Host Country (5 MARKS)
• Capital inflow & FDI → creates productive assets.
• Technology & know-how transfer.
• Employment generation & skill development.
• Export promotion & foreign exchange earnings.
• Backward & forward linkages → stimulates local suppliers and distributors.
• Infrastructure development (roads, power, ports).
• Increased competition → forces local firms to become efficient.

4. Disadvantages for Host Country (4 MARKS)
• Crowding-out of local firms & market domination.
• Repatriation of huge profits → drain on foreign exchange.
• Transfer pricing → reduces tax revenue.
• Focus on high-profit luxury goods instead of basic needs.
• Limited technology transfer (core R&D kept at home).
• Enclave economy → weak linkages with local economy.
• Environmental degradation & labour exploitation in weak-regulation countries.

5. Advantages & Disadvantages for Home Country (2 MARKS)
Advantages: Higher global profits, repatriated earnings, enhanced competitiveness, overseas jobs for home-country managers.
Disadvantages: Export of jobs & capital, loss of domestic tax revenue due to transfer pricing, possible “hollowing out” of manufacturing base.

Conclusion:
TNCs are powerful engines of globalisation. For host countries (especially developing ones), they bring capital, technology and export opportunities but also pose risks of dependency, profit repatriation and market dominance. Home countries gain global profits but may lose domestic jobs and tax revenue. Overall impact depends on the host country’s bargaining power and policy framework.

Memory Aid (Mnemonic)
Why TNC → “M-T-R-E-T-R-H” (Market-Tariff-Resource-Efficiency-Technology-Risk-Host incentives)
Host (+) → “C-T-E-E-L-I-C” (Capital-Tech-Employment-Export-Linkages-Infrastructure-Competition)
Host (–) → “C-R-T-L-E” (Crowding-Repatriation-Transfer pricing-Luxury focus-Enclave)
Q8
What were the basic reasons for setting up the International Monetary Fund (IMF)? Has the IMF succeeded in achieving its objectives? Enumerate the constraints faced by the IMF in carrying out its operations (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
1. Basic Reasons for Setting up the IMF (6 MARKS)
• Post-World War II chaos destroyed the international payments system.
• Need to avoid competitive devaluations and “beggar-thy-neighbour” policies of the 1930s.
• Many countries faced acute balance-of-payments deficits and needed short-term finance.
• Requirement of a multilateral institution to oversee exchange rates and promote orderly currency arrangements.
• To establish a code of conduct for current account payments and removal of exchange restrictions.
• To provide temporary financial assistance with safeguards for correcting BOP disequilibrium.

2. Objectives of the IMF (as per Articles of Agreement)
1. Promote international monetary cooperation.
2. Facilitate expansion and balanced growth of international trade.
3. Promote exchange stability and orderly exchange arrangements.
4. Assist in establishing a multilateral system of payments.
5. Provide temporary financial resources to correct maladjustments with adequate safeguards.
6. Shorten duration and lessen degree of disequilibrium in international BOP.

3. Has the IMF Succeeded? (6 MARKS)
Yes – Successes:
• Maintained a multilateral payments system (Article VIII convertibility).
• Prevented return to 1930s-style competitive devaluations.
• Provided massive financial assistance (tranches, EFF, SAF, ESAF, etc.).
• Created SDRs to supplement gold & dollar reserves.
• Played key role in debt rescheduling and structural adjustment.

No / Partial failure:
• Could not prevent collapse of Bretton Woods fixed exchange rate system in 1971–73.
• Unable to control volatile capital flows and currency crises (1997 Asian crisis, 2008 global crisis).
• Conditionality often criticised as too harsh and “one-size-fits-all”.
• Increasing irrelevance of quota-based resources compared to private capital markets.

4. Constraints Faced by the IMF (6 MARKS)
• Limited resources (quotas too small compared to global capital flows).
• Unequal voting power (USA has veto power; developing countries underrepresented).
• Conditionality and political interference reduce member acceptance.
• Dependence on domestic policy implementation (IMF can recommend but not enforce).
• Moral hazard – countries may take excessive risks knowing IMF will bail them out.
• Shift from current-account to capital-account crises reduced its effectiveness.
• Lack of jurisdiction over capital controls and global financial regulation.

Conclusion:
The IMF was created to restore order in the post-war monetary system and has largely succeeded in preventing a return to the chaos of the 1930s. It continues to play a crucial role in crisis lending and surveillance, but its resources, governance structure and tools need continuous reform to remain relevant in a world dominated by private capital flows.

Memory Aid (Mnemonic) “IMF GOALS”
I → International monetary cooperation
M → Multilateral payments system
F → Financial assistance for BOP deficits
G → Growth of trade & income
O → Orderly exchange rate system
A → Avoid competitive devaluations
L/S → Limits: Resources, voting, Lopsided power, Stringent conditionality