MCO–04

BUSINESS ENVIRONMENT

Note: Attempt all questions. All questions carry equal marks.
1(a)
“The impact of macro-environment forces varies from firm to firm even if they belong to the same industry.” Comment on this statement. (8 MARKS)
8 MARKS
Introduction (1 Mark)

Macro-environment refers to broad external forces (PESTLEG) that affect all organisations in an industry. These forces are generally uniform for the entire industry, yet their actual impact varies significantly from firm to firm even within the same sector. This variation arises due to differences in firm-specific resources, strategies, capabilities, vision, and adaptability.

Why Impact Varies – Detailed Explanation (6 Marks)

Macro ForceUniform ForceWhy Impact Differs (Examples)
Economic High interest rates, inflation, rupee depreciation Large firms (Reliance, Tata) can raise funds easily; SMEs face credit crunch → Maruti vs small auto ancillary units
Political-Legal New GST law, labour code changes Firms with strong compliance teams (Infosys) adapt fast; unorganised players struggle
Socio-Cultural Shift to health consciousness Patanjali gains hugely; traditional namkeen brands lose market share
Technological Arrival of 5G, AI, EVs Tesla-ready firms (Tata Motors) benefit; traditional ICE players (some two-wheeler firms) face disruption
Demographic Young population, rising middle class Byju’s, Nykaa, Zomato explode; firms targeting senior citizens grow slowly
Ecological/Global Carbon tax, ESG norms, global recession Green-certified firms (ITC, Ultratech) attract funds; high-emission firms face penalties


Conclusion (1 Mark)
Same macro-environment → different outcomes because internal factors (resources, strategy, leadership, culture) act as filters. Firms that continuously scan, adapt, and build dynamic capabilities convert threats into opportunities while others perish.

Memory Anchor (Super Easy)
EPSTLE-G → Economic, Political, Socio-cultural, Technological, Legal, Ecological, Global
“Same Storm, Different Boats”
1(b)
Explain the need for environmental scanning in the current business environment context. (12 MARKS)
12 MARKS
Introduction (2 Marks)

Environmental scanning is the systematic process of collecting, analysing, and disseminating information about external (macro & micro) and internal factors affecting the organisation. In today’s VUCA (Volatile, Uncertain, Complex, Ambiguous) and hyper-competitive globalised world, it is no longer optional — it is a survival imperative.

Necessity of Environmental Scanning – 9 Key Reasons (9 Marks)

1. Complexity & Inter-connectedness → Economic, political, technological forces are deeply interlinked (e.g., Russia-Ukraine war → global inflation).
2. Identify Opportunities & Threats Early → Jio identified 4G opportunity; Kodak missed digital photography threat.
3. Strategic Planning & Goal Setting → Realistic objectives only possible with accurate environmental insights.
4. Rapid Technological Disruption → AI, Blockchain, EVs, Metaverse demand constant vigilance.
5. Intense Competition & Market Trends → Track competitors (Patanjali vs HUL), changing consumer preferences (plant-based meat).
6. Regulatory & Legal Compliance → Frequent changes in GST, Data Protection Bill, labour codes — non-compliance invites heavy penalties.
7. Enhances Organisational Adaptability → Builds learning culture; firms become proactive, not reactive.
8. Risk Identification & Mitigation → Anticipate recessions, supply chain disruptions (COVID lesson), political instability.
9. Drives Innovation & Growth → Insights spark new products (Patanjali Ayurveda boom after health consciousness trend).

Conclusion (1 Mark)
Environmental scanning acts as the “radar system” of modern business. It converts uncertainty into foresight, threats into opportunities, and ensures long-term sustainability in a turbulent world.

Memory Anchor (Super Easy)
COST-CAFIR → Complexity, Opportunity-Threat, Strategy, Technology, Competition, Adaptability, Forecasting, Innovation, Risk management
Q2
Discuss the role of SEBI in regulating the issue of capital. Also, explain its role in shareholder protection. (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
Introduction (2 Marks)

The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) was established in 1988 and given statutory status in 1992 under the SEBI Act, 1992. It is the apex regulator of the Indian securities and capital market. SEBI’s twin objectives are: (i) development of a fair, transparent and efficient capital market, and (ii) protection of investors’ interests. It performs the roles of quasi-legislative, quasi-executive and quasi-judicial body.

A. Role of SEBI in Regulating Issue of Capital (10 Marks)

FunctionDetailed RoleKey Regulations
1. Disclosure & Transparency Ensures full, fair and accurate disclosure in offer documents so investors can take informed decisions. SEBI (ICDR) Regulations, 2018 – DRHP, RHP, Prospectus vetting
2. Pricing of Issues Allows free pricing (fixed price or book-building) but prevents over/under-valuation. Book-building guidelines, ASBA mandatory
3. Underwriting & Allotment Monitors fair allotment, prevents cornering of shares, mandates proportionate allotment. No preferential allotment to promoters beyond limits
4. Regulation of Intermediaries Registers and supervises merchant bankers, underwriters, registrars, brokers, DPs. SEBI (Merchant Bankers) Regulations, 1992
5. Prevention of Fraud & Misuse Prohibits misleading statements, price rigging, insider trading during IPO period. SEBI (Prohibition of Fraudulent and Unfair Trade Practices) Regulations, 2003
6. Listing & Post-Issue Compliance Ensures timely listing, lock-in of promoter shares, minimum public shareholding (25%). SEBI (LODR) Regulations, 2015


B. Role of SEBI in Shareholder Protection (8 Marks)

AreaSEBI’s Protective Measures
1. Minority Shareholder RightsMandatory e-voting, postal ballot, independent directors, audit committee
2. Takeovers & Substantial AcquisitionSEBI (SAST) Regulations, 2011 – Open offer to public shareholders at fair price
3. Insider Trading PreventionSEBI (PIT) Regulations, 2015 – Disclosure of trades by insiders, trading plans
4. Grievance RedressalSCORES platform – Online complaint filing & tracking
5. Investor Education & AwarenessRegular campaigns, resource materials, financial literacy programmes
6. Corporate GovernanceRegulation 17–27 of LODR – Board composition, related-party transactions approval, secretarial audit
7. Delisting & Buy-backFair exit opportunity to shareholders


Conclusion (2 Marks)
SEBI has transformed India’s capital market from a speculative, opaque system into one of the most regulated and investor-friendly markets globally. From Harshad Mehta (1992) to post-SEBI era, investor confidence has dramatically risen. Its balanced approach of market development + investor protection has made India the fastest-growing major equity market in the world.

Memory Anchor (Super Easy)
Capital Issue: D-P-U-F-L-I → Disclosure | Pricing | Underwriting | Fraud control | Listing | Intermediaries
Shareholder Protection: M-I-G-S-C-O-R-E → Minority rights | Insider trading | Governance | SAST | SCORES | Education
Q3
“India is on its way to becoming a developed economy.” Justify this statement on the characteristics of a developed money market. (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
Introduction (2 Marks)

A money market is a well-organised segment of the financial market dealing in short-term funds (up to one year). A developed money market is an essential hallmark of a developed economy because it ensures efficient liquidity management, effective monetary policy transmission, and low-cost short-term finance. India’s money market has undergone massive transformation post-1991 liberalisation and now exhibits almost all characteristics of a developed money market.

Characteristics of a Developed Money Market vs India’s Position (16 Marks)

CharacteristicGlobal BenchmarkIndia’s Present Status (Evidence)Marks
1. Strong & Independent Central Bank Fed, ECB, BoE RBI is among the most respected central banks. Uses Repo, Reverse Repo, CRR, SLR, LAF, MSF effectively. 2
2. Wide Network of Commercial Banks & DFIs Deep banking penetration PSBs + Pvt banks + Foreign banks + RRBs + Payment Banks + SFBs + Co-operative banks → huge reach. 1.5
3. Multiple Integrated Sub-Markets Call, Notice, Repo, CBLO, T-Bills, CP, CD All active: Call Money, Repo, Tri-party Repo, T-Bills (91/182/364 days), CP, CD, Collateralised Borrowing and Lending Obligation (CBLO now TREPS). 2
4. Variety of Sophisticated Instruments Diverse short-term papers T-Bills, Cash Management Bills, CP, CD, Repo, Reverse Repo, Commercial Bills (rare but exist). 2
5. High Degree of Integration & Uniformity of Rates Single yield curve Rates in Call, Repo, CP, CD, T-Bills move closely with RBI’s policy rate corridor (Repo ± 0.5%). LAF has harmonised rates. 2
6. Active Participation of Non-Bank Entities Mutual funds, corporates, NBFCs MFs (liquid & overnight funds), Primary Dealers, NBFCs, Corporates, Insurance Cos, FPIs actively participate. 1.5
7. Well-Developed Secondary Market & Discount Houses DFHI, active secondary trading Discount & Finance House of India (DFHI), now replaced by active PDs, CCIL, NDS-OM, TREPS platform. 1.5
8. Ample Supply of Short-Term Funds High liquidity Daily turnover in Call/Repo market often exceeds ₹2–3 lakh crore. T-Bill market size > ₹10 lakh crore. 1
9. Technological & Institutional Modernisation Electronic, screen-based trading NDS-OM, CROMS, E-Kuber, RTGS, NEFT, TREPS, guaranteed settlement by CCIL. 1.5
10. Global Integration FPIs, offshore linkage FPIs allowed in T-Bills, CP, CD; G-Sec fully opened under FAR; India in global bond indices (2024–25). 1.5


Remaining Minor Gaps (1 Mark)
- Rural penetration still low
- Commercial Bills market underdeveloped
- Corporate bond repo not fully mature

Conclusion (2 Marks)
India’s money market today satisfies 95%+ of the characteristics of a developed money market. The depth, breadth, integration, technology, and regulatory oversight are comparable to many advanced economies. This sophisticated money market is a strong testimony that India has already acquired one of the most critical pillars of a developed economy and is firmly on the path to becoming the world’s third-largest economy by 2030.

Memory Anchor (Super Easy)
CSI³–RITG → Central Bank | Sub-markets | Instruments | Integration | Interest uniformity | Institutions | Innovation | Technology | Global linkage
Q4
Discuss the role of the Competition Commission of India (CCI). Also, share the various duties and powers of this commission. (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
Introduction (2 Marks)

The Competition Commission of India (CCI) is a statutory body established under the Competition Act, 2002 (amended in 2007 & 2023). It replaced the erstwhile MRTP Act, 1969. CCI is India’s anti-trust regulator whose primary objective is to eliminate practices having adverse effect on competition, promote and sustain competition, protect consumer interests and ensure freedom of trade.

A. Role of CCI in the Indian Economy (8 Marks)

RoleDescriptionReal Impact
1. Prevents Anti-Competitive Agreements Prohibits cartels, bid-rigging, price-fixing, market allocation ₹6,000+ crore penalties on cement cartel (2012), beer cartel (2021)
2. Curbs Abuse of Dominance Stops predatory pricing, exclusive deals, denial of market access Google (₹1,337 Cr + ₹936 Cr), MakeMyTrip, Amazon, Flipkart cases
3. Regulates Combinations (M&A) Pre-merger notification & approval above thresholds Reviewed 900+ mergers; blocked only 1 (Jet-Etihad modified)
4. Protects Consumer Welfare Ensures fair prices, choice, quality & innovation Lower prices post cartel busting; better services
5. Market Studies & Advocacy Studies e-commerce, pharma, telecom; issues advisories E-commerce report (2020), Pharma study → policy changes
6. Promotes Competitive Neutrality Ensures level-playing field between private & PSU firms Actions against Indian Railways, Coal India dominance


B. Duties of CCI (Section 18) – (5 Marks)

1. Eliminate practices having adverse effect on competition
2. Promote and sustain competition in markets
3. Protect the interests of consumers
4. Ensure freedom of trade carried on by other participants
5. Conduct market studies and competition advocacy
6. Issue guidelines and regulations
7. Advise government on competition policy

C. Powers of CCI (5 Marks)

PowerDetails
1. Inquiry & InvestigationSuo-motu, on complaint, or govt reference (DG office)
2. Cease & Desist OrdersDirect companies to stop anti-competitive behaviour
3. PenaltyUp to 10% of average turnover of 3 years OR 3 times cartel profit (2023 amendment)
4. Structural RemediesOrder division of enterprise (rare)
5. Merger ControlApprove, modify, or block combinations
6. Search & Seizure (Dawn Raids)Like IT dept raids (post-2009 amendment)
7. Leniency ProgrammeLesser penalty for whistle-blowers in cartels (up to 100% waiver for first applicant)
8. AppealOrders appealable to NCLAT → Supreme Court


Conclusion (2 Marks)
From a virtually non-existent competition regime in 2002, CCI has emerged as one of the most proactive and respected anti-trust regulators globally. Its actions against Big Tech, cement cartels, pharma companies and e-commerce giants have ensured that India’s rapidly growing markets remain competitive, innovative and consumer-friendly. CCI is a key institution driving India’s journey towards becoming a $10 trillion competitive economy.

Memory Anchor (Super Easy)
Roles → PAD-CAM → Prevent agreements | Abuse of dominance | Combinations | Advocacy | Market studies
Powers → “CCI Can SEARCH & PUNISH”
Suo-motu | Enquiry | Cease | Penalty | Approval (merger) | Raid | Compensation | Hub-and-spoke | Leniency
5(a)
Explain the role of Small Industrial Development Organisation (SIDO) and Small Industries Service Institute (SISI) in developing small-scale industry in India. (10 MARKS)
10 MARKS
Introduction (1 Mark)

SIDO (now Office of Development Commissioner – MSME) is the apex body under Ministry of MSME, established in 1954. Small Industries Service Institutes (SISI), now renamed MSME-Development Institutes (MSME-DIs), are its field-level arms located in almost every state.

Role of SIDO & SISI/MSME-DIs (8 Marks)

FunctionSIDO (Policy Level)SISI / MSME-DI (Field Level)
1. Policy FormulationFrames national MSME policy, schemes (PMEGP, ZED, CLCSS)Implements policies at ground level
2. Entrepreneurship DevelopmentDesigns EDP, SDP, MDP curriculaConducts 6-week EDPs, skill training, awareness camps
3. Technical ConsultancySets standardsProject reports, machinery selection, layout, quality improvement, ISO consultancy
4. Marketing AssistanceOrganises India International MSME Expo, NSIC tie-upsVendor development programmes, buyer-seller meets, barter fairs, international trade fairs
5. Cluster DevelopmentSFAC, MSE-CDP schemesIdentifies & develops 500+ clusters (e.g., Tiruppur knitwear, Agra footwear)
6. Credit FacilitationCredit Guarantee Fund Trust (CGTMSE), PMEGPHelps in bank loan documentation, CGTMSE registration
7. Technology UpgradationZED Certification, Lean Manufacturing, IncubationTechnology centres (Tool Rooms), testing labs, common facility centres
8. Data & ResearchAnnual MSME Report, CensusDistrict Industrial Potential Surveys


Conclusion (1 Mark)
SIDO and SISI/MSME-DIs have been the backbone of India’s 63+ million MSMEs which contribute 30% to GDP and 45% to exports. Their integrated policy + field approach has made India the global leader in number of MSMEs.

Memory Anchor: SIDO = “Policy Maker” | SISI = “Hand-holder on Ground”
5(b)
Discuss various export promotion measures taken by the Indian government in the last decade. (10 MARKS)
10 MARKS
Introduction (1 Mark)

In the last decade (2014–2025), India’s exports crossed $770 billion (2023–24) due to aggressive export promotion under “Make in India”, FTP 2015–20 (extended), RoDTEP, PLI schemes, etc.

Major Export Promotion Measures (8 Marks)

Scheme/InitiativeKey FeaturesImpact
1. Foreign Trade Policy 2015–20 & RoDTEP (2020)Replaced MEIS; Remission of Duties & Taxes on Exported Products (1–4% incentive)Neutralised embedded taxes, helped $450+ bn merchandise exports
2. Production Linked Incentive (PLI) Scheme₹1.97 lakh crore across 14 sectors (mobile, pharma, solar, textiles)Made India global hub for mobile phones (Apple, Samsung)
3. Export Promotion Capital Goods (EPCG)Zero-duty import of capital goodsHelped modernisation
4. SEZ & EoU ReformsBaba Kalyani Committee reforms, SEZ Act amendmentsImproved ease of doing business
5. Districts as Export Hubs (DEH)One District One Product (ODOP) → 739 districts mappedGi-tagged products (Banaras saree, Darjeeling tea)
6. TIES & MAI SchemesTrade Infrastructure for Export Scheme, Market Access InitiativeUpgraded ports, airports, convention centres
7. Interest Equalisation Scheme (IES)3–5% interest subvention for MSME exportersExtended till 2024
8. Krishi Udan & Agri-Export PolicyAir freight subsidy for agri productsFresh fruits/flowers to Middle East & Europe
9. FTAs & GIFT CityUAE, Australia, UK FTAs; India International Bullion ExchangeDiamond & gold re-exports boosted


Conclusion (1 Mark)
The last decade witnessed a shift from pure incentives to production-linked, infrastructure-backed, district-level export promotion — taking India from $314 bn (2013–14) to $770+ bn exports and making it one of the top 10 exporting nations.

Memory Anchor: RoDTEP-PLI-DEH-TIES-IES-FTA → “Real Power Daily To India’s Export Future”
6(a)
What is the role of World Trade Organization in promoting global trade? (10 MARKS)
10 MARKS
Introduction (1 Mark)

The World Trade Organization (WTO), established on 1st January 1995, succeeded GATT (1947). It is the only global body dealing with rules of trade between nations. Its core objective is to ensure trade flows as smoothly, predictably and freely as possible.

Key Roles of WTO in Promoting Global Trade (8 Marks)

RoleDescriptionImpact
1. Administers Trade AgreementsGATT, GATS, TRIPS, Plurilateral AgreementsBinding rules for 98% of world trade
2. Reduces Tariffs & NTBs164 members bound by MFN & National TreatmentAvg. global tariff fell from 40% (1947) to ~4% now
3. Dispute Settlement MechanismDSB – binding, time-bound (600+ cases settled)India won 23 out of 26 cases as complainant
4. Trade Policy Review Mechanism (TPRM)Periodic review of members’ policiesEnsures transparency
5. Special & Differential TreatmentLonger transition periods for developing nationsIndia uses S&D in agriculture, pharma
6. Trade Facilitation Agreement (TFA)Simplifies customs proceduresIndia ratified in 2016 → reduced clearance time
7. Aid for Trade & Capacity BuildingTechnical assistance to LDCsIndia receives & provides training
8. Forum for Trade NegotiationsDoha Round, Nairobi, MC12 outcomesFisheries subsidy agreement (2022)


Conclusion (1 Mark)
WTO has increased global trade from $58 billion (1948) to over $28 trillion (2023). Despite criticisms (slow decision-making, agriculture deadlock), it remains the cornerstone of rule-based multilateral trading system.

Memory Anchor: WTO = MFN + DSB + TRIPS + TFA
6(b)
Explain the role of IPRs (Intellectual Property Rights) in global business environments. (10 MARKS)
10 MARKS
Introduction (1 Mark)

Intellectual Property Rights (IPRs) are legal rights granted to creators over their inventions, designs, brands, literary & artistic works. TRIPS Agreement (1995) under WTO made IPR protection mandatory globally.

Role of IPRs in Global Business (8 Marks)

RoleBenefit to BusinessIndian Example
1. Encourages Innovation & R&DRecovers huge R&D cost via monopoly profitsPharma (Cipla, Dr. Reddy’s), IT (TCS, Infosys)
2. Attracts FDI & Technology TransferCompanies invest only where IP is safeApple, Samsung, Pfizer plants in India
3. Builds Brand ValueTrademarks create global recognitionTata, Amul, Patanjali, Zomato
4. Enables Licensing & FranchisingEarn royalties without physical presenceHollywood films, Starbucks, Domino’s
5. Prevents Counterfeiting & PiracyProtects revenue & reputationLuxury brands, Bollywood fights piracy
6. Enhances Export CompetitivenessGI tags boost premium pricingDarjeeling Tea, Banarasi Saree, Basmati
7. Supports Start-ups & ValuationIP is major asset for fundingByju’s, Ola, Flipkart patents


Conclusion (1 Mark)
In knowledge economy, IPRs are the new currency of global business. Strong IPR regime is the reason USA, Japan, Germany dominate high-value exports while India is rapidly moving from generic drugs to novel drug discovery.

Memory Anchor: IPRs = R&D + FDI + Brand + Licensing + Anti-Piracy + GI + Valuation
Q7
Differentiate between the following: (5×4 = 20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
(a) Monopolistic Trade Practices vs Restrictive Trade Practices (5 Marks)
BasisMonopolistic Trade Practices (MTP)Restrictive Trade Practices (RTP)
ObjectiveMaintain/grow dominanceRestrict competition
ExamplesPredatory pricing, limit supplyTie-in sales, resale price maintenance, exclusive dealing
EffectUnreasonable high profitsUnfair trade practices harming consumers
Section (MRTP Act)Section 2(o), 31Section 2(p), 33

(b) Pre-Issue vs Post-Issue Obligations by SEBI (5 Marks)
BasisPre-IssuePost-Issue
StageBefore opening of issueAfter closure
FocusDisclosure & transparencyAllotment, refund, listing
Key ActivityDRHP filing, ASBA, marketingBasis of allotment, demat credit, listing within 3 days (T+3)

(c) Mahalanobis Strategy vs New Development Strategy (5 Marks)
BasisMahalanobis (2nd FYP)New Strategy (1991 onwards)
FocusHeavy industries, self-relianceLiberalisation, privatisation, globalisation
Role of StateCommanding heightsFacilitator, regulator
TradeImport substitutionExport promotion, FDI

(d) Patent vs Invention (5 Marks)
BasisInventionPatent
MeaningNew technical solutionExclusive legal right granted for invention
DurationLifetime of idea20 years from filing
RequirementNovelty, inventive step, industrial useRegistration with Patent Office


Memory Anchor for Q7: M-R-P-M → Monopolistic-Restrictive | Pre-Post | Mahalanobis-New | Patent-Invention
Q8
Write short notes on the following: (5×4 = 20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
8(a) Income Distribution Patterns in India (5 Marks)

Income distribution refers to how national income is shared among individuals/households. In India, despite high GDP growth, income inequality has increased sharply.

AspectCurrent Reality (2024–25)
Gini Coefficient0.38–0.42 (World Bank); among highest in Asia
Top 1% ShareCaptures ~22–25% of national income (World Inequality Lab)
Top 10% Share~57% of total income
Bottom 50%Only ~13–15% of income
Rural–Urban GapAverage urban income 1.7–2 times rural
Regional DisparityMaharashtra, Karnataka, TN vs Bihar, UP, Odisha
OccupationalIT/professionals earn 10–15× agricultural labour
Gender GapWomen earn 20–30% less than men for same work

Causes: Skill-biased growth, unequal education, asset ownership, informal sector dominance.
Conclusion: Rising inequality threatens social stability and inclusive growth; hence need for progressive taxation, skill development, rural industrialisation.

8(b) Social Accounting and Reporting Approaches (5 Marks)

Social accounting measures and reports an organisation’s social and environmental performance beyond financial profits (Triple Bottom Line: People, Planet, Profit).

ApproachDescriptionExample
1. Classical/EthicalBased on moral duty towards society (Gandhian trusteeship)Tata Group’s historical philanthropy
2. DescriptiveQualitative narration of social activitiesEarly CSR reports
3. Cost–Benefit AnalysisMonetises social costs & benefitsITC e-Choupal ROI calculation
4. Social Indicators MethodUses KPIs (employment generated, water saved, diversity ratio)BRSR metrics
5. Net Social ContributionNet benefit = Social benefits – Social costsUsed in sustainability reports

Mandatory in India: Business Responsibility & Sustainability Reporting (BRSR) for top 1000 listed companies (SEBI, 2021).
Conclusion: Social accounting promotes transparency, accountability and helps companies earn “social licence to operate”.

8(c) Environment Protection Laws in India (5 Marks)

India has a comprehensive framework for environmental protection rooted in the Constitution and various statutes.

Law/ActYearKey Provision
Constitution1976 (42nd Amendment)Art 48A (State duty), Art 51A(g) (Citizen duty)
Water Act1974CPCB & SPCBs, consent mechanism
Air Act1981National Ambient Air Quality Standards
Environment (Protection) Act1986Umbrella Act → EIA 1994 & 2006, CRZ, Hazardous Waste Rules
Forest (Conservation) Act1980 (amended 2023)Compensatory afforestation, net present value
Wildlife Protection Act1972 (amended 2022)6 Schedules, Project Tiger, NTCA
NGT Act2010Fast-track environmental justice

Conclusion: India’s environmental jurisprudence (precautionary principle, polluter pays, public trust doctrine) is among the most progressive globally.

8(d) Workers’ Participation in Management (WPM) (5 Marks)

Workers’ Participation in Management refers to involvement of employees in decision-making processes at various levels.

LevelFormsIndian Example
Shop Floor / Works CommitteeInformation sharing, consultationFactories Act 1948 – mandatory in >500 workers
Joint Management CouncilsConsultative bodies (1958 scheme)Tata Steel, BHEL
Worker DirectorRepresentation on BoardPublic sector banks, SAIL
Collective BargainingNegotiation via unionsStrong in Maruti, Bajaj Auto
Self-Management / Co-ownershipESOPs, worker cooperativesInfosys, Wipro ESOPs; AMUL, Lijjat Papad

Benefits: Higher motivation, reduced conflict, better productivity, industrial democracy.
Challenges: Resistance from management, union rivalry, low awareness.
Conclusion: Successful Indian companies (Tata, Infosys, AMUL) prove that genuine WPM leads to win-win outcomes.

Memory Anchors for Q8
(a) Top 1% = 25% income (b) BRSR + Cost-Benefit (c) 48A-51A(g) + EPA 1986 (d) Works Committee → Board Director
Q9
Discuss the role of Technological Environment in framing Technology Policy Statement. Also explain the various technology transfer practices. (20 MARKS)
20 MARKS
Introduction (2 Marks)

The Technological Environment comprises the level of scientific knowledge, rate of technological change, R&D infrastructure, innovation ecosystem and global technology flows that surround a nation. India’s first Technology Policy Statement (TPS) was announced in 1983 and later updated through Science & Technology Policy 2003, STI Policy 2013 and Draft National STI Policy 2021. The evolution of these policies has been a direct response to the changing domestic and global technological environment.

Role of Technological Environment in Framing India’s Technology Policy (10 Marks)

Aspect of Technological EnvironmentHow it Influenced TPS/STI PoliciesKey Policy Response
1. Post-Independence Technology Gap Heavy dependence on imported technology in capital goods, defence, pharma Emphasis on self-reliance, reverse engineering, creation of CSIR labs, public sector R&D
2. Global Technological Revolution (1970s–80s) Rise of microelectronics, computers, biotechnology TPS-1983 focused on mastering imported technology, strengthening S&T infrastructure, promoting indigenous development
3. 1991 Liberalisation & FDI Inflow Entry of MNCs with latest technology Shift from import substitution to selective import + absorption + innovation (STP-2003)
4. Rise of Knowledge Economy & IT Boom India became global IT/BPO leader STI Policy 2013 aimed at “positioning India among top 5 global scientific powers”
5. 4th Industrial Revolution (AI, IoT, Robotics, 5G) Rapid global disruption Draft STI Policy 2021 & National Strategy on AI, Blockchain, Quantum, Deep Tech focus
6. Climate Change & Sustainability Challenge Need for green technologies National Mission on Sustainable Development, Solar Alliance, Hydrogen Mission
7. Geopolitical Technology Restrictions US-China tech war, semiconductor shortages ₹76,000 crore Semiconductor Mission, PLI for electronics, Atmanirbhar Bharat


Technology Transfer Practices (8 Marks)

Mode of TransferDescriptionIndian Examples
1. Foreign Direct Investment (FDI) MNCs bring latest plant & machinery, processes Samsung Noida (world’s largest mobile plant), Suzuki Gujarat
2. Licensing & Franchising Right to use patents, trademarks, know-how Domino’s, McDonald’s, pharmaceutical molecules
3. Joint Ventures & Technical Collaboration Equity + technology partnership Maruti-Suzuki (1982–2007), Mahindra-Renault
4. Turnkey Projects Complete plant supplied & installed BHEL, L&T in power & metro projects
5. Technical Consultancy & EPC Design & engineering services Tata Projects, Engineers India Ltd.
6. Reverse Engineering & Adaptation Copy + improve imported technology Indian generic pharma industry (Cipla, Ranbaxy)
7. Government-to-Government Transfer Defence, space, nuclear Rafale (ToT), ISRO-NASA collaboration, BrahMos
8. Academia–Industry Linkages Incubation, sponsored research IITs, IISc, TIFAC, BIRAC, Atal Innovation Mission


Conclusion (2 Marks)
India’s technology policy has continuously evolved in response to the changing technological environment — from self-reliance (1983) → absorption + innovation (2003) → global leadership in emerging tech (2021). Effective technology transfer practices have transformed India from a technology importer in 1980s to the world’s third-largest start-up ecosystem and a major exporter of IT, pharma and space services today. The future lies in mastering deep-tech and becoming a global technology provider rather than just a consumer.

Memory Anchor (Super Easy)
Technology Policy Evolution: 1983 → Self-Reliance | 2003 → Absorption | 2013 → Innovation | 2021 → Global Leadership
Transfer Modes: FDI → License → JV → Turnkey → Consultancy → Reverse → G2G → Academia